Nipple Confusion: What the Evidence Says About Bottles and Pacifiers
By Breastfeeding Mom Editorial TeamUpdated 6 min read
You may have been told that giving a bottle too early will “confuse” your baby and ruin breastfeeding. You may also have heard the opposite: that nipple confusion is a myth. The truth sits in between. Some babies do struggle when they switch between breast and bottle, but whether the bottle is the cause, and how much risk it adds, is still not settled.
Here’s what the research actually says, what else can look like nipple confusion, and what you can do about it. For a bigger picture of early feeding, visit the common challenges hub.
What people mean by nipple confusion
A 2015 review by Zimmerman and Thompson defines it as an infant’s difficulty with, or preference for, one feeding mechanism over another after exposure to artificial nipples. Cleveland Clinic describes the signs as difficulty breastfeeding after exposure to a bottle, or difficulty bottle feeding after being breastfed.
A pediatrician quoted by Cleveland Clinic points out that babies can’t tell us they’re confused. It may be more of a preference: a bottle’s flow is faster and starts right away, with no wait for a let-down, so some babies take the path of least resistance. Other babies prefer the breast, perhaps because of closeness, a relaxed pace or habit, and refuse the bottle.
What the research says
The evidence is mixed and mostly observational, and the main problem is working out cause and effect.
| Source | What it found | Limits |
|---|---|---|
| Zimmerman and Thompson, 2015 (review of 14 articles) | Emerging evidence of nipple confusion with bottles; very little evidence with pacifiers | It’s hard to know whether bottles cause breast refusal or are simply markers of other maternal or infant factors. The authors call for more research. |
| Howard et al., 2003 (randomized trial, 700 newborns) | Giving supplements, by cup or bottle, shortened breastfeeding overall. Early pacifier use (days 2 to 5) was linked with less exclusive breastfeeding at 4 weeks and shorter overall duration. | An older trial. It found no overall difference between cup and bottle supplements. The authors concluded that avoiding artificial nipples in the newborn period made sense, but the Cochrane review below, which looked at pacifiers on their own, found no effect at 3 to 4 months. |
| Cochrane review, 2016 (2 trials, 1,302 babies) | Pacifier use in healthy term babies had no significant effect on exclusive or partial breastfeeding at 3 or 4 months | The review says evidence on short-term breastfeeding difficulties and long-term infant health is lacking. |
| ABM Protocol #3, 2017 | No evidence that any supplemental feeding method is unsafe or necessarily better. There is some evidence that avoiding artificial nipples for supplements may help return to exclusive breastfeeding | Optimal device not identified; little research on different bottle nipples |
Cleveland Clinic adds that nipple confusion is not an official diagnosis, and that only about half of pediatricians believe frequent bottle feeding causes it. Zimmerman and Thompson note the debate is partly driven by two conflicting statements: the AAP’s 2005 advice to offer a pacifier to protect against SIDS, and the WHO’s 2009 statement that breastfeeding infants should never be given artificial nipples. WHO’s revised Ten Steps (step 9) now call for counseling mothers on the use and risks of bottles, teats and pacifiers.
The NHS puts it plainly: there is a small amount of evidence that babies may not breastfeed as well because they learn a different sucking action at the bottle.
What else can look like nipple confusion
Cleveland Clinic warns that “nipple confusion” can be too simple an explanation. Similar problems may come from:
- Low milk production. Cleveland Clinic lists it among the problems that can be mistaken for nipple confusion. See how to increase milk supply.
- Nipple pain or a poor latch. If feeding hurts, using a bottle for relief is natural, but the baby may then get used to the faster flow. The root problem is the latch. See does breastfeeding hurt.
- Tongue-tie or other oral issues. ABM Protocol #26 (on persistent breastfeeding pain) links restricted tongue movement to latch difficulty and nipple pain. See tongue tie.
- A slower start at the breast. With a bottle your baby feeds right away, while at the breast the let-down may take a few minutes. If your baby gets frustrated waiting, Cleveland Clinic suggests hand expressing a little milk first.
How to lower the odds
None of these steps is proven to prevent nipple confusion. They’re reasonable, low-risk precautions that sources suggest.
- Wait until breastfeeding is going well, if you can. Cleveland Clinic suggests holding off on bottles until you have a solid routine. The NHS says it can take several weeks for you and your baby to feel confident, and that bottles of formula alongside breastfeeding can reduce the amount of milk you make. For pacifiers, the AAP says to wait until breastfeeding is established, meaning your milk supply is good, feeding is comfortable and consistent, your baby latches well and is gaining weight as they should.
- Use paced bottle feeding. Hold the bottle close to horizontal, use a slow-flow nipple and let your baby pause. The ABM says pacing may be beneficial, especially for preterm infants. Cleveland Clinic’s pediatrician suggests a rate of about 1 oz (30 ml) every 5 minutes. See paced bottle feeding and our guide to bottles for breastfed babies.
- Think about how you supplement. If your baby needs extra milk, the ABM lists options including a supplemental nursing system at the breast, cup, spoon, syringe, finger feeding or bottle, and says an optimal device hasn’t been identified. Discuss the choice with your care team. See combination feeding.
- Make the first bottles easy. The NHS suggests offering them when your baby is happy and relaxed, asking someone else to give them and trying a different position from breastfeeding.
- Don’t wait until your baby is frantic. Cleveland Clinic says a very hungry baby can’t latch easily, regardless of nipple confusion. Feed at early hunger cues, and if you need to calm your baby first, try skin-to-skin contact.
- Be cautious with nipple shields. Cleveland Clinic says they’re rarely helpful for this and can reduce milk transfer. Get help from a lactation consultant if you think you need one. See nipple shield.
- Think carefully about pacifiers. They’re linked with lower SIDS risk, and the AAP advises offering one at nap time and bedtime once breastfeeding is established. Our guide to pacifiers for breastfed babies goes into more detail.
If your baby already prefers the bottle
Stay calm. Preferences can change. The NHS suggests holding your baby skin-to-skin, expressing milk regularly (about 8 times a day, including once at night, is described as ideal) to protect your supply, feeding often when your baby will latch and choosing times when your baby is relaxed and alert but not too hungry. It also says not to force your baby to stay at the breast, and to cut back on bottles gradually as your supply increases. The NHS also describes a lactation aid (a tiny tube taped next to your nipple that delivers milk while your baby is at the breast) as a way to support a baby who is getting used to the breast, and says your midwife, health visitor or breastfeeding supporter can tell you more.
When to call a doctor or lactation consultant
Reach out to an IBCLC, your pediatrician or your midwife if:
- Your baby repeatedly refuses the breast or fusses and pulls away at every feed
- Your baby has fewer wet or dirty diapers than expected, or isn’t gaining weight
- Feeding is painful, or you notice your milk supply dropping
- You’re pumping or giving bottles and worry about your supply
Our breastfeeding support page lists where to find help. If a recent loss of interest in the breast comes suddenly, with a baby who was previously feeding well, our guide to a nursing strike may also help.
Frequently asked questions
Can pacifiers cause nipple confusion?
The evidence is thin. A 2015 review found very little evidence linking pacifiers to nipple confusion, and a Cochrane review of two trials with 1,302 healthy breastfed babies found no significant effect of pacifier use on exclusive breastfeeding at 3 or 4 months. The AAP still advises waiting to offer one until breastfeeding is established.
Does a slow-flow bottle prevent nipple confusion?
Nobody knows for sure. The Academy of Breastfeeding Medicine says some experts recommend a wide-base, slow-flow nipple to mimic breastfeeding, but little research has compared outcomes with different bottle nipples. Slow flow and paced feeding are low-risk steps to try.
Should I avoid bottles completely?
Not necessarily. WHO's Ten Steps to Successful Breastfeeding call for counseling mothers on the use and risks of bottles, teats and pacifiers. If you need to give bottles, for work or any other reason, the practical steps in this article can reduce problems.
What if my baby refuses the bottle instead of the breast?
Bottle refusal is common. The NHS suggests giving the first few bottles when your baby is happy and relaxed rather than very hungry, asking someone else to give them so your baby isn't near the smell of your milk, and trying a different position than you use for breastfeeding.
Sources
- Zimmerman E, Thompson K. Clarifying nipple confusion. J Perinatol, 2015https://europepmc.org/article/MED/26181720
- Cochrane: Effect of restricted pacifier use in breastfeeding term infants for increasing duration of breastfeeding (2016)https://europepmc.org/article/MED/27572944
- Howard CR, et al. Randomized clinical trial of pacifier use and bottle-feeding or cupfeeding and their effect on breastfeeding. Pediatrics, 2003https://europepmc.org/article/MED/12612229
- Academy of Breastfeeding Medicine Clinical Protocol #3: Supplementary Feedings in the Healthy Term Breastfed Neonate, Revised 2017https://europepmc.org/article/MED/28294631
- Cleveland Clinic: What Is Nipple Confusion? Myths and Helphttps://health.clevelandclinic.org/nipple-confusion
- NHS: How to combine breast and bottle feedinghttps://www.nhs.uk/baby/breastfeeding-and-bottle-feeding/bottle-feeding/combine-breast-and-bottle/
- HealthyChildren.org (AAP): How to Keep Your Sleeping Baby Safe: AAP Policy Explainedhttps://www.healthychildren.org/English/ages-stages/baby/sleep/Pages/A-Parents-Guide-to-Safe-Sleep.aspx
- WHO: Ten steps to successful breastfeedinghttps://www.who.int/teams/nutrition-and-food-safety/food-and-nutrition-actions-in-health-systems/ten-steps-to-successful-breastfeeding
This guide is general information, not medical advice. For your own situation, talk to your doctor, midwife, pharmacist or an IBCLC lactation consultant. Read our medical disclaimer and find breastfeeding support near you.
Related articles
Nursing Strike: Why Your Baby Suddenly Refuses the Breast and What to Do
A baby who suddenly refuses the breast is usually on a nursing strike, not weaning. Here's why it happens and how to gently get back to breastfeeding.
Nipple Shield: When It Helps, How to Use It and How to Wean Off
A nipple shield can rescue a tricky latch, but it isn't a fix for everything. Learn when it helps, how to fit and use it, and how to wean off.
Triple Feeding: What It Is, Why It's Used and How to Step Down
Triple feeding means breastfeeding, then supplementing, then pumping. Learn why it's used, how to make it manageable and how to step down with your care team.
Sore Nipples While Breastfeeding: Causes and Relief
Why breastfeeding can make your nipples sore or cracked, what helps them heal, what the evidence says about lanolin, and when to get help.



